I’m setting up a guest room and the current king mattress is on the softer side, which some visitors find too sink-in. I came across a 4-inch king memory foam topper online that claims to add plush support, but I’m worried that adding four inches on top of an already soft mattress will just make things mushier and harder to get out of.
The room gets used maybe a dozen nights a year, so I don’t want to spend a lot, but I also don’t want guests waking up with back aches. I’m uncertain whether a 4-inch layer is meant for firm mattresses only, or whether it can work on a soft base if the foam density is high enough. There’s also the question of sheets — deeper toppers seem to need deeper pockets.
Has anyone here tried a 4-inch topper on a soft mattress? Did it actually firm things up or make it worse? I’d appreciate hearing what worked for you.